Centereach, New York, is a great place to live and is one of Long Island’s more affordable places to buy a house. The village of Centereach – sited within the town of Brookhaven – is home to plentiful shopping, has convenient access to both the Northern State Parkway and the Long Island Expressway, and is within 4 miles of the Ronkonkoma station of the Long Island Railroad. As it is located midway between Brooklyn and Montauk, Centereach homeowners can easily make a day trip to either end of the Island. Additionally, MacArthur Airport is located just twelve miles outside the village.
Centereach History and Postwar Expansion
Originally inhabited by the Setauket and Nissequogue Native American tribes, European settlers began arriving in the Centereach area in the late 18th century. The name “Centereach” was adopted in the early 20th century when residents began petitioning for a post office. After World War II, Centereach became an attractive suburban destination for many families seeking to escape the crowded city. The development of highways and good roads facilitated commuting to and from Centereach, making it a viable option for those working in New York City or other parts of Long Island.
Centereach Resources and Amenities
Centereach residents have access to many attractive community resources and amenities. The highly rated Middle Country Central School District provides educational services to Centereach, as well as Selden, parts of Lake Grove, Coram, Lake Ronkonkoma, Port Jefferson Station, and Farmingville. This school district includes eight elementary schools, two middle schools, two high schools, and a special education learning center. Centereach residents can also avail themselves of a top-notch library and public pool complex. In terms of parks, the Percy B. Raynor Memorial Park provides playing fields for athletic activities.
Shopping possibilities abound in Centereach, which has its own Walmart, along with dozens of restaurants and other retail establishments sited along Middle Country Road. Just a few minutes away in Lake Grove, you’ll find the Smith Haven Mall, with 1.3 million square feet of retail space hosting more than 140 stores.
Housing Styles and Lot Sizes in Centereach
Because a large portion of the housing stock in Centereach was built after World War II, you’ll find an abundance of Cape Cod, Ranch, Minimal Traditional, and Split-Level styles. Some, but not all, of these homes incorporate roomy (often 2-car) garages within their structures. In terms of lot size, lots in Centereach range from 5,000 square feet up to 20,000 square feet and beyond. While million-dollar homes are not unheard of in Centereach, home values (at the time of this writing) tend to cluster in the $500,000 to $700,000 range.
Want to Learn More About Centereach? Give Team Rita a Call
Centereach is a great choice for families wishing to enjoy a relaxed suburban lifestyle with excellent community resources and good access to transportation. If you’re interested in settling here, Team Rita – whose home base is right in Centereach on Middle Country Road – would love the opportunity to introduce you to an attractive residential property that will exceed your expectations.
Contact Team Rita today to schedule viewings or find out about Open Houses in Centereach, New York. Schedule a free consultation with one of our real estate agents. Team Rita can help with selling and buying your next dream home.
- List View
- Map View
- Grid View
-
-
Lot Size10,019 sqft
-
Home Size1,023 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1960
-
Days on Market5
-
-
-
Lot Size21,780 sqft
-
Home Size1,600 sqft
-
Beds4 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1970
-
Days on Market7
-
-
-
Lot Size10,019 sqft
-
Home Size2,074 sqft
-
Beds5 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1977
-
Days on Market7
-
-
-
Lot Size6,099 sqft
-
Home Size648 sqft
-
Beds2 Beds
-
Baths1 Bath
-
Year Built1930
-
Days on Market7
-
-
-
Lot Size11,762 sqft
-
Home Size1,440 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths4 Baths
-
Year Built1957
-
Days on Market8
-
-
-
Lot Size14,811 sqft
-
Home Size1,016 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1974
-
Days on Market9
-
-
-
Lot Size10,890 sqft
-
Home Size1,200 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths1 Bath
-
Year Built1935
-
Days on Market12
-
-
-
Lot Size6,099 sqft
-
Home Size690 sqft
-
Beds2 Beds
-
Baths1.5 Baths
-
Year Built1954
-
Days on Market14
-
-
-
Lot Size12,197 sqft
-
Home Size1,080 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1956
-
Days on Market14
-
-
-
Lot Size9,148 sqft
-
Home Size2,024 sqft
-
Beds6 Beds
-
Baths3.5 Baths
-
Year Built1967
-
Days on Market14
-
-
-
Lot Size10,890 sqft
-
Home Size2,013 sqft
-
Beds4 Beds
-
Baths1.5 Baths
-
Year Built1968
-
Days on Market18
-
-
-
Lot Size16,989 sqft
-
Home Size2,586 sqft
-
Beds5 Beds
-
Baths3 Baths
-
Year Built1955
-
Days on Market19
-
-
-
Lot Size9,584 sqft
-
Home Size1,580 sqft
-
Beds5 Beds
-
Baths4 Baths
-
Year Built1957
-
Days on Market19
-
-
-
Lot Size33,977 sqft
-
Home Size1,424 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1900
-
Days on Market20
-
-
-
Lot Size9,148 sqft
-
Home Size840 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths1.5 Baths
-
Year Built1945
-
Days on Market21
-
-
-
Lot Size9,584 sqft
-
Home Size1,300 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1968
-
Days on Market27
-
-
-
Lot Size13,068 sqft
-
Home Size2,236 sqft
-
Beds5 Beds
-
Baths3 Baths
-
Year Built1963
-
Days on Market28
-
-
-
Lot Size9,148 sqft
-
Home Size2,400 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths2.5 Baths
-
Year Built1954
-
Days on Market40
-
-
-
Lot Size10,019 sqft
-
Home Size1,443 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths1.5 Baths
-
Year Built1960
-
Days on Market41
-
See all Real estate matching your search.
(all data current as of
5/12/2026)
Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Read full disclaimer.