Lake Grove Homes for Sale

Lake Grove – a village in the town of Brookhaven with a population of about 11,000, is an excellent choice for individuals and families looking to put down roots in Suffolk County. Lake Grove offers a quiet, family-friendly suburban environment with highly rated schools, convenient access to shopping and amenities, and a reputation for safety.

History and Postwar Expansion
Lake Grove was originally occupied by Native Americans of the Setauket tribe. Initially an agricultural area, like much of Long Island, Lake Grove developed gradually as European settlers moved into the region. The community’s name likely derives from its wooded areas near bodies of water. Lake Grove’s growth was influenced by broader developments on Long Island, including the expansion of the Long Island Railroad in nearby areas, which improved connectivity and spurred development. However, Lake Grove remained a relatively small, unincorporated community for much of its history, only officially becoming a village in 1968. This transition from farmland to suburb reflects the broader pattern of development seen across much of Long Island over the past two centuries.

Housing Styles and Lot Sizes
Lake Grove showcases a diverse range of residential architectural styles typical of Long Island suburbs. Its housing stock primarily reflects mid-to-late 20th century development, with a predominance of Ranch-style homes, Cape Cod houses, and Split-levels. Colonial Revival designs are also common, alongside raised ranches and some contemporary suburban homes. While less frequent, one might occasionally encounter Craftsman-inspired elements in newer or renovated properties. This architectural mix mirrors the town’s growth patterns, with most styles dating from the post-World War II era through the 1970s, though more recent constructions have introduced modern variations.

Residential lot sizes in Lake Grove are typical of many Long Island suburbs, generally ranging from 1/4 to 1/2 acre (roughly 10,000 to 20,000 square feet). This size range provides homeowners with modest yards while maintaining the area’s suburban character. While some properties may have larger lots up to an acre or more, these are less common. Conversely, newer developments might feature slightly smaller lots. While residential estate prices on Long Island have appreciated greatly in recent years, Lake Grove remains one of the more affordable communities in Suffolk County. Currently, the median sale price for a single-family home in Lake Grove is $660,000, with condos and co-ops available at lower price points.

Village Resources and Amenities
Lake Grove offers a mix of local and regional amenities to its residents. The Smith Haven Mall, a major shopping center, is located within the village, providing extensive retail options, including Trader Joe’s and Whole Foods. Several parks and recreational areas are available, including Lake Grove Village Park, which offers sports fields and playgrounds. The nearby Stony Brook University campus provides cultural and educational opportunities. For outdoor enthusiasts, Lake Grove’s location provides easy access to beaches and larger parks in the surrounding areas of Long Island.

Want to Learn More About Lake Grove? Give Team Rita a Call
Lake Grove is a great choice for anyone wishing to enjoy a quality suburban lifestyle with excellent community resources, affordable housing, and good access to transportation. If you’re interested in settling here, Team Rita – whose home base is in Centereach (just a few miles from Lake Grove) – would love to introduce you to an attractive residential property that will exceed your expectations.

Contact Team Rita today to schedule viewings or find out about Open Houses in Lake Grove, New York. Schedule a free consultation with one of our real estate agents. Team Rita can help with selling and buying your next dream home in Suffolk County.

See all Real estate matching your search.
(all data current as of 4/20/2025)

Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Read full disclaimer.