If you’re looking for a peaceful, yet conveniently located community, Holbrook, New York, might be the perfect place for you. Situated in the Town of Islip in Suffolk County, Holbrook is home to around 26,500 residents. It’s surrounded by a variety of charming neighboring towns like Centereach, Holtsville, Sayville, Bohemia, Patchogue, Lake Grove, and Ronkonkoma, giving residents a peaceful suburban lifestyle with easy access to everything Long Island and New York City have to offer.
Holbrook has a rich history that dates back to the 1800s, originally settling as an agricultural community. It was named after the Holbrook family, early settlers who helped shape the area. Over the years, Holbrook transitioned from farming land to a growing residential neighborhood, especially after the arrival of the Long Island Railroad in the late 1800s. Today, the hamlet combines its rural roots with modern development, offering a quiet, suburban charm that attracts families and professionals alike.
Getting around is easy in Holbrook, thanks to major roads like the Long Island Expressway (I-495) and Sunrise Highway (NY-27), providing quick access to other parts of Long Island and New York City. While the Holbrook train station closed in 1962, nearby stations in Ronkonkoma and Medford offer convenient Long Island Railroad service. Plus, Long Island’s MacArthur Airport is just a few miles away, making it even easier to travel for both business and leisure.
Holbrook is also known for its great schools, as it falls within the Sachem Central School District. The district includes top-rated schools such as Merrimac Elementary, Seneca Middle School, and Sachem High Schools North and East. Education is a priority in the community, with about 93% of residents having completed high school and a third holding a bachelor’s degree or higher.
For those who love the outdoors, Holbrook offers plenty of recreational opportunities. The area boasts various parks, sports fields, and other facilities to keep residents active. And with nearby beaches, fishing spots, and cultural venues, there’s always something to do in this vibrant community.
The real estate market in Holbrook offers something for everyone, whether you’re looking for a spacious single-family home, a townhouse, or a more modern development. Many homes are nestled in quiet, tree-lined neighborhoods that offer a suburban feel while being conveniently close to major roads and public transport. Holbrook continues to be a sought-after area due to its desirable location and family-friendly atmosphere.
Whether you’re raising a family or simply looking for a pleasant place with easy access to nature and city life, Holbrook strikes the perfect balance. If you’re ready to find your dream home, contact Team Rita today! Our experienced agents can help you discover the best homes in Holbrook and guide you through the buying or selling process with ease. Contact Team Rita to schedule a free consultation to learn more about homes for sale or upcoming Open Houses in the area!
- List View
- Map View
- Grid View
-
-
Lot Size4,792 sqft
-
Home Size2,437 sqft
-
Beds4 Beds
-
Baths2.5 Baths
-
Year Built1990
-
Days on Market2
-
-
-
Lot Size23,523 sqft
-
Home Size1,528 sqft
-
Beds5 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1876
-
Days on Market2
-
-
-
Lot Size21,780 sqft
-
Home Size1,600 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1950
-
Days on Market4
-
-
-
Lot Size15,246 sqft
-
Home Size1,948 sqft
-
Beds5 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1962
-
Days on Market9
-
-
-
Lot Size13,504 sqft
-
Home Size988 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1985
-
Days on Market10
-
-
-
Lot Size11,326 sqft
-
Home Size2,036 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths1.5 Baths
-
Year Built1965
-
Days on Market16
-
-
-
Lot Size10,019 sqft
-
Home Size2,477 sqft
-
Beds5 Beds
-
Baths2.5 Baths
-
Year Built1976
-
Days on Market18
-
-
-
Lot Size10,019 sqft
-
Home Size1,216 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1967
-
Days on Market33
-
-
-
Lot Size11,762 sqft
-
Home Size1,759 sqft
-
Beds4 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1969
-
Days on Market40
-
-
-
Lot Size9,148 sqft
-
Home Size1,492 sqft
-
Beds5 Beds
-
Baths1 Bath
-
Year Built1965
-
Days on Market42
-
-
-
Lot Size7,841 sqft
-
Home Size2,420 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths3 Baths
-
Year Built1931
-
Days on Market45
-
-
-
Lot Size11,762 sqft
-
Home Size936 sqft
-
Beds2 Beds
-
Baths1.5 Baths
-
Year Built1930
-
Days on Market53
-
-
-
Lot Size10,890 sqft
-
Home Size2,178 sqft
-
Beds4 Beds
-
Baths2.5 Baths
-
Year Built1969
-
Days on Market61
-
-
-
Lot Size7,841 sqft
-
Home Size2,140 sqft
-
Beds4 Beds
-
Baths2.5 Baths
-
Year Built1974
-
Days on Market64
-
-
-
Lot Size9,148 sqft
-
Home Size2,002 sqft
-
Beds4 Beds
-
Baths2.5 Baths
-
Year Built1977
-
Days on Market64
-
-
-
Lot Size20,474 sqft
-
Home Size1,516 sqft
-
Beds3 Beds
-
Baths2 Baths
-
Year Built1952
-
Days on Market65
-
-
-
Lot Size3,921 sqft
-
Home Size1,109 sqft
-
Beds2 Beds
-
Baths1.5 Baths
-
Year Built1973
-
Days on Market79
-
-
-
Lot Size6,970 sqft
-
Home Size1,740 sqft
-
Beds4 Beds
-
Baths2.5 Baths
-
Year Built1974
-
Days on Market87
-
See all Real estate matching your search.
(all data current as of
11/19/2026)
Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Read full disclaimer.