Looking for a beautiful place to call home on Long Island? East Setauket might be just what you’re after. This charming hamlet in the Town of Brookhaven offers a peaceful, suburban vibe with historic character, excellent schools, and easy access to parks, shops, and nearby towns. It’s part of the highly respected Three Village Central School District and is close to Stony Brook University, major roads, and the Port Jefferson branch of the Long Island Rail Road—so commuting is a breeze.
A Town Full of History—and Growth
East Setauket has a long and fascinating history. Settled in the 1600s, it played a key role in the American Revolution as home to the Culper Spy Ring, a secret group that passed vital information to George Washington. You can still see that history today in the well-preserved colonial homes and landmarks like the Setauket Village Green and Caroline Church.
After World War II, East Setauket grew steadily, especially as Stony Brook University expanded. Roads like Route 25A and Nicolls Road made it easier for people to get here, and neighborhoods began to grow—though the area has kept its calm, leafy character. Today, around 11,000 people call East Setauket home.
Homes and Property Types
East Setauket offers a nice mix of old and new when it comes to homes. Near the historic district, you’ll find lovely Colonial and Federal-style homes. Other parts of town feature Cape Cods, ranches, split-levels, and modern contemporary houses. Newer developments include custom-built homes and townhouses, giving buyers plenty of choices.
Most homes sit on one-third acre to over an acre, especially in quieter, wooded parts of town. While Long Island real estate has gone up in value, East Setauket remains a solid investment. The median home price here is currently over $750,000, with options ranging from cozy starter homes to large estate-style properties.
Community Highlights and Amenities
There’s so much to love about living in East Setauket. You’re surrounded by nature, with local spots like Frank Melville Memorial Park, Setauket Mill Pond, and Patriots Hollow State Forest perfect for walking, kayaking, or just enjoying the fresh air.
You’re also just minutes from Stony Brook Village Center, where you’ll find unique shops, restaurants, and seasonal events. And top-quality healthcare is nearby, thanks to Stony Brook University Hospital. Families appreciate the area’s libraries, community centers, and reliable public services.
The Three Village Central School District is a major draw, especially for families. Ward Melville High School consistently earns high marks for its academics, science programs, and arts education.
Fun and Activities for All Ages
East Setauket is a great place for kids and families. There are community sports leagues, parks with basketball courts and ball fields, and plenty of trails for walking or biking. The Three Village Swim Club and Stony Brook Athletics offer even more ways for young people to stay active.
And for something a little more relaxed, the Emma S. Clark Memorial Library—one of the oldest in New York—offers programs, lectures, and cultural events for all ages.
Want to Learn More About East Setauket? Team Rita Can Help
If East Setauket sounds like your kind of place, we’d love to show you around. With its mix of history, nature, strong schools, and convenient location, it’s no wonder so many people are proud to call it home.
Team Rita, based just down the road in Centereach, knows East Setauket inside and out. Whether you’re buying, selling, or just exploring your options, we’re here to help every step of the way.
Give Team Rita a call today to learn more, schedule a showing, or find out about upcoming open houses in East Setauket, NY. Let’s find your perfect home together.