Farmingville Homes for Sale

The hamlet of Farmingville in Suffolk County is a part of the town of Brookhaven, New York. Farmingville borders the communities of Holtsville, Medford, Selden, and Ronkonkoma. Today, Farmingville is home to approximately 15,000 residents.

History and Postwar Expansion
Farmingville’s roots trace back to the colonial era when settlers arrived on Long Island in the 17th century. Originally part of the Town of Brookhaven, which was established in 1655, Farmingville began as a sparsely populated farming community. Early European settlers were attracted to the area because of its fertile soil, ideal for growing crops such as corn, wheat, and potatoes. These agricultural activities became Farmingville’s economic backbone for much of its early history.

After World War II, Farmingville experienced a significant transformation, mirroring trends across Long Island. The post-war economic boom and the GI Bill made it easier for returning veterans to buy homes, which sparked a wave of suburban growth. Farmland was sold to developers, who turned open fields into neighborhoods filled with new houses to keep up with the growing demand.

A major turning point was the construction of the Long Island Expressway (LIE), finished in 1958. Suddenly, commuting to New York City or other parts of Long Island became much easier, making Farmingville a perfect spot for families looking for a peaceful suburban lifestyle. Affordable housing and the area’s quiet charm attracted many new residents, fueling a housing boom in the 1950s and 1960s.

As Farmingville grew, so did its local infrastructure. Schools, shopping centers, and parks popped up to serve the community, turning the area into a welcoming and convenient place to live. This shift from a rural farming hamlet to a bustling suburban neighborhood laid the foundation for the community we know today.

Housing Styles and Lot Sizes
You’ll find a variety of mid-century housing designs in Farmingville, including ranches, cape cods, and split-levels, which were popular in the 1950s and 1960s. Over time, additional housing styles such as colonials, Victorians, and more modern construction have also been introduced, adding to Farmingville’s architectural diversity.

Lot sizes in Farmingville tend to be generous by suburban standards, reflecting its origins as a rural farming community. Most homes sit on quarter-acre to half-acre lots, offering spacious yards that are ideal for families. Some properties, particularly older or custom-built ones, may feature even larger lots, while newer developments or smaller homes may have more modest lot sizes. This variety ensures a range of options for prospective homeowners, from first-time buyers to those looking for more expansive properties.

Village Resources and Amenities
Farmingville offers residents a rich variety of resources and amenities that make it a desirable suburban community. Outdoor enthusiasts can enjoy parks like Bald Hill Cultural Park, local playgrounds, and nearby nature trails in the Pine Barrens. The well-regarded Sachem Central School District serves families, while Suffolk County Community College provides opportunities for higher education.

Shopping plazas, restaurants, and essential services are conveniently located in Farmingville, and the Long Island Expressway and Suffolk County Transit buses make commuting easy, with access to the Long Island Railroad nearby in Ronkonkoma. Community services include the Sachem Public Library, Brookhaven Town Hall, and nearby healthcare facilities like Stony Brook University Hospital. Residents also benefit from seasonal events, farmers’ markets, youth recreation programs, and senior services, creating a well-rounded, family-friendly environment with a strong sense of community.

Interested in moving to Farmingville? Contact Team Rita today to schedule a viewing or find out about Open Houses in Farmingville, New York. Schedule a free consultation with one of our real estate agents and let Team Rita find your next dream home or sell your current home.

See all Real estate matching your search.
(all data current as of 2/21/2025)

Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Read full disclaimer.