>

Compare Listings

The Town of Southold, perched on Long Island’s North Fork, offers a beautifully tranquil yet vibrant East End lifestyle. With its mix of historic hamlets, sweeping waterfronts, and pastoral farmland, Southold attracts buyers who want a blend of coastal charm, rural peace, and long-term real estate value. 

A Rich, Quiet Character
Southold is one of Long Island’s oldest communities, with deep colonial roots and a strong maritime tradition. The town includes several hamlets, each with its own feel, from the waterfronts of Greenport and Peconic to inland agricultural areas. With a population of roughly 6,600 as of 2023, Southold retains a low-density, small-town quality.  

The social fabric of Southold leans into its rural and seasonal rhythms: only about 58% of housing units are occupied year-round, while 37% serve as seasonal or second homes. This seasonal dynamic helps maintain a quiet, retreat-like atmosphere, but also contributes to a limited inventory of year-round housing. 

Because Southold is served by its own Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) station, residents have an easy and dependable way to travel both west toward New York City and east through the North Fork.  

Lifestyle & Local Appeal
Residents of Southold enjoy easy access to miles of North Fork shoreline, vineyards, farmland, and historic hamlets. Boating, fishing, farm stands, and wine-tasting are part of day-to-day life for many. The town’s slower pace and natural beauty make it especially appealing for those seeking respite from more densely populated areas, with an authentic East End character that doesn’t feel overly commercialized. 

Real Estate Landscape
As of 2025, Southold’s housing market reflects the prestige and exclusivity of the North Fork. According to Zillow, the average home value in Southold is around $1.10 million, a slight decline of about 1.3% over the previous year. Redfin data similarly reports a median sale price of $1,148,500, with prices per square foot near $579, though homes are staying on the market somewhat longer compared to hotter resort markets.  

Housing Types, Lot Sizes & Affordability
Housing in Southold is dominated by single-family homes, many of which are historic, waterfront, or situated on larger parcels. According to the town’s comprehensive plan, a substantial portion of homes are seasonal; only about 10% of units are rentals available year-round. On the more affordable end, the Southold Town housing registry (from 2021)  lists homes as low as $560,000 for modest residences. But the broader market skews high, driven by demand for vacation homes, waterfront properties, and large lot sizes. 

Southold Market Outlook (& What Buyers Should Know) 

  • Strong but stable values: While Southold housing values have softened slightly in some recent reports, the area remains high-value, especially for waterfront or historic properties. 
  • Seasonal inventory dynamics: With many homes being second homes, year-round supply is tight. This can make competition steeper for full-time buyers. 
  • Long-term appeal: The town’s character, limited development, and land scarcity make it likely to remain a highly desirable North Fork location. 
  • Cost considerations: Buyers should account for potentially high property taxes, maintenance on larger or older homes, and the premium for waterfront or vineyard-adjacent parcels. 

Ready to explore homes for sale in Southold, NY?
For buyers looking for a peaceful, scenic, and culturally rich place to live, or to invest in a second home, Southold offers an unbeatably authentic North Fork experience. Its mix of historic charm, farmland, bays, and vineyards delivers a lifestyle that is deeply rooted to the land, yet still connected to the amenities and prestige of the East End. 

Contact Team Rita today to browse current listings, access market insights, and get help finding the right property, whether you want a year-round home, a weekend retreat, or a long-term investment. Contact Team Rita today to schedule a free consultation or to learn more about available homes in Southold. Proudly serving all of Suffolk County, Team Rita is your trusted partner for Long Island real estate success. 


Sorted by
151 - 167 of 167 | Previous Page 6 of 6 Next
  • List View
  • Map View
  • Grid View
  1. 4 Beds,  2 Baths
    1,800 sqft   lot 5,228 sqft
    MLS 940213
    344 Days on Market
  2. 4 Beds,  3 Baths
    2,200 sqft   lot 18,731 sqft
    MLS 942025
    348 Days on Market
  3. 4 Beds,  1.5 Baths
    1,880 sqft   lot 3.10 ac
    MLS 934356
    375 Days on Market
  4. 6 Beds,  6.5 Baths
    5,920 sqft   lot 1.33 ac
    MLS 894818
    392 Days on Market
  5. 3 Beds,  2 Baths
    1,650 sqft   lot 21,780 sqft
    MLS 921412
    410 Days on Market
  6. 3 Beds,  1.5 Baths
    2,400 sqft   lot 17,424 sqft
    MLS 906405
    439 Days on Market
  7. 4 Beds,  3.5 Baths
    2,857 sqft   lot 10,455 sqft
    MLS 909423
    441 Days on Market
  8. 4 Beds,  3 Baths
    1,930 sqft   lot 8,712 sqft
    MLS 908511
    445 Days on Market
  9. 5 Beds,  7.5 Baths
    8,505 sqft   lot 3.30 ac
    MLS 907439
    445 Days on Market
  10. 4 Beds,  4.5 Baths
    2,914 sqft   lot 34,413 sqft
    MLS 893733
    483 Days on Market
  11. 4 Beds,  5 Baths
    4,929 sqft   lot 33,977 sqft
    MLS 875189
    527 Days on Market
  12. 3 Beds,  3.5 Baths
    3,610 sqft   lot 27,008 sqft
    MLS 837910
    533 Days on Market
  13. 8 Beds,  7 Baths
    5,600 sqft   lot 2.28 ac
    MLS 859020
    562 Days on Market
  14. 5 Beds,  4 Baths
    4,200 sqft   lot 1.02 ac
    MLS 828203
    633 Days on Market
  15. 3 Beds,  1.5 Baths
    2,000 sqft   lot 1.74 ac
    MLS L3590177
    742 Days on Market
  16. 5 Beds,  4.5 Baths
    3,500 sqft   lot 9,540 sqft
    MLS L3579812
    792 Days on Market
  17. 5 Beds,  4.5 Baths
    4,900 sqft   lot 39,814 sqft
    MLS L3528746
    1,024 Days on Market
Previous Page 6 of 6 Next

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc.
The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use.

Information Copyright 2026, Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

This IDX Website is powered by Diverse Solutions 2026. Privacy | Terms & Conditions