>

Compare Listings

Save to Favorites
Print
Share
PRICE $2,500,000 dsIDX morgage calculator
BEDS 4
BATHS 3
HOME SIZE 3,097 sqft
LOT SIZE 1.80 ac

Discover a one-of-a-kind Shelter Island retreat where historic farmhouse charm meets inspired modern living. Set amid 1.8 acres of mature trees, tall privets, sun-drenched edged lawns, and open green space, this circa-1900 property offers a rare combination of character, privacy, and flexibility. The original 2-story residence showcases beautiful period details, including traditional moldings, hand-hewn beams, wood floors, and distinctive vintage glass windows. Inside, 3 bedrooms and 2 baths are complemented by comfortable living and dining rooms, a thoughtfully updated chef's kitchen with a casual dining area, and a screened porch perfect for long summer evenings. A remarkable addition completed in 2005 is the approximately 1,300-square-foot artist's atelier, featuring radiant-heated floors and an upper-level primary suite that opens onto a spacious rooftop deck. A detached guest cottage adds another dimension to the property, offering independent accommodations with a large bedroom, full bath, kitchen, living room, and its own garden and lawn. A charming outbuilding provides yet another opportunity, whether envisioned as a reading nook or hobby space. With its blend of historic architecture, dedicated studio space, separate guest quarters, and generous grounds, the property invites a variety of possibilities, including the potential for a swimming pool. Equally suited to relaxed summer gatherings or comfortable year-round living, this is a distinctive island sanctuary with room to create something truly your own.

DAYS ON MARKET 37 LAST UPDATED 11/19/2026
YEAR BUILT 1900 COUNTY Suffolk
STATUS Active PROPERTY TYPE(S) Single Family

SCHOOLS
Elementary School Shelter Island School
Jr. High School Shelter Island School
High School Shelter Island School

PRICE HISTORY
Prior to Oct 16, '26 $2,500,000
Oct 16, '26 - Nov 19, '26 $3,250,000
Nov 19, '26 - Today $2,500,000


ADDITIONAL DETAILS
AIR None
APPLIANCES Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Cooktop, Gas Oven, Washer
BASEMENT Partial
CONSTRUCTION Cedar
HEAT Hot Water, Propane
INTERIOR Sauna
LOT 1.8 acre(s)
PARKING Driveway
SEWER Septic Tank
STYLE Farmhouse
TAXES 10021.76
UTILITIES See Remarks
WATER Private, Well
MORTGAGE CALCULATOR
   

TOTAL MONTHLY PAYMENT

0
P
I
*Estimate only

SATELLITE VIEW



 
CONTACT US ABOUT 20 BALDWIN ROAD
 / 
We respect your online privacy and will never spam you. By submitting this form with your telephone number you are consenting for Rita Tsoukaris to contact you even if your name is on a Federal or State "Do not call List".

Listed with Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc.
The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use.

Information Copyright 2026, Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

This IDX solution is (c) Diverse Solutions 2026.